HOA Insights: Common Sense for Common Areas
We exist to help all 2 million volunteer HOA Boardmembers nationwide have the right information at the right time to make the right decisions for the future of their community association. Stay with us weekly for actionable insights that minimize stress, avoid catastrophes, and protect property values!
Watch On Youtube
Shop!
HOA insights now has its very own merch store! Our team has whipped up some hats, mugs, T-Shirts, & more that we think Volunteer HOA Boardmembers are gonna love. We also offer dozens of FREE zoom backgrounds. Available in our Boardmember Merch Store!
Support Our Sponsors
Association Insights & Marketplace
Association Reserves
Community Financials
Kevin Davis Insurance Services
Stoke Light Video & Marketing
The Inspectors of Election
HOA Insights: Common Sense for Common Areas
002 | Condo Termination/De-Conversion: Know Your Emergency Exit!
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Today Robert Nordlund has guests Eben Hansel & Roger Winston to talk about Condo Termination/De-conversion and why it’s important to you!
❗Join our LIVE Podcast April 1st 2024 on Youtube! 👉 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=24KbKsKyoNY
✅ Is a Reserve Study right for you? 👉 https://www.reservestudy.com/
Everybody should locate their “emergency exit” before going on a journey. The same is true for an association traveling into the future. Associations are not necessarily designed to physically or economically last forever. In this episode we learn about the association “Termination” or “De-Conversion” process, where a shared ownership association reverts to single-owner status. Learn why this happens, how, and when. As an “emergency exit” it is rarely employed (only hundreds have occurred in the USA), yet it is best to know that this exit strategy exists.
Contact Information from today's guests:
Eben Hansel: https://www.ballardspahr.com/people/attorneys/h/hansel-eben
Roger Winston: https://www.ballardspahr.com/people/attorneys/w/winston-Roger
Chapters from today's episode:
00:00 Hostel Takeover
01:00 Intro to Eben Hansel & Roger Winston
02:59 What is Condo Termination?
08:27 Is there HOA & CO-OP termination?
10:56 Challenges with condo termination
13:39 The two ways condo termination can go
16:10 The difference between a CO-OP and a condo
20:28 Are there certain situations that unite home owners to sell all at the same time?
24:52 What does it look like when a developer is driving a condo termination?
32:09 First steps you can make if your community is being taken over by a condo termination
Podcast Links:
Full Episode List
Watch On Youtube
Engage in the conversation!
Call our 24/7 voicemail line at (805) 203-3130 or send an email or voice memo to podcast@reservestudy.com
Nominate yourself or a Board Hero you Know!
Board Hero Nominations
Boardmember Merch Store!
Connect with Hosts on LinkedIn
Julie Adamen
Kevin Davis, CIRMS
Robert Nordlund, PE
Support Our Sponsors
Association Insights & Marketplace
Association Reserves
Community Financials
Kevin Davis Insurance Services
Stoke Light Video & Marketing
The Inspectors of Election
A developer who buys up a large portion of the units could have the ability to take over an association, you know, to hold the voting power in the association. They could turn around and sell the property to themselves. There are all sorts of permutations of that that are not really adequately addressed by a lot of the state laws. Starts to sound a little bit like a hostile takeover of a publicly traded company when someone buys large chunks of the shares of the stock. I am squirming in my chair just hearing about those kinds of things. Common sense for common areas exists to help all 2 million volunteer board members nationwide have the right information at the right time to make the right decisions for their future. This podcast is sponsored by four companies that care about board members, Association Insights and Marketplace Association, Reserves, Community Financials, and Kevin Davis Insurance Services. You'll find links to their websites and social media in the show notes. Welcome back to Common Sense for Common Areas. I'm Robert Nordlund and I'm here today with two special guests to discuss condo termination or deconversion. And you're likely to think, what is that and why do I care? Well, those are fair questions, but that's exactly why it's important that we bring this episode to you today. This is our episode number two. And before I introduce our topic and our two guests, I want to encourage everyone to check out episode number one, which was a great discussion with co-host and sponsor Kevin Davis of Kevin Davis Insurance Services. We tell the story of our background and the events that led to the creation of this podcast. So back to today's episode. Think about it shortly after you're seated on an airplane, before you take off, the flight attendants go through a safety procedure and they encourage you to look around and see where your emergency exits are and last week, I went on a date with my wife and in the theater, as the lights began to dim over the loudspeaker, we heard a voice welcoming us to the show, encouraging us to silence our cell phones and again asking us to look around and identify where the emergency exits are. And that combination of events was enough to have us decide that this particular episode belongs in our number two slot. So we want to welcome you to the podcast. And early in the series, make sure you know where the emergency exit is. So today we have two attorneys with us, Eben Hansel and Roger Winston of the national law firm Ballard Spahr. Eben and Roger are respectively from their Baltimore and Washington, D.C. offices. They came to my attention a few months ago when they wrote a paper on condo termination. While I quickly learned they're experts in their field and they have a heart for community associations and board members. So welcome, Eben. Welcome, Roger. Thank you. Hi Robert, great to be here So now tell us, what is condo termination? Yeah. So condo termination is kind of the flip side of condo creation. And I think most people who are listening to this podcast are probably familiar with the process of forming a condominium, as most people know. Each state has its own condominium laws. And to form a condominium, you file a document in the land records a condominium declaration. A condominium termination is really the reverse of that process. You take an existing condominium and file paperwork in the land records to terminate it or de-convert it. And the result of that is the condominium ceases to exist and the property returns to the status that it was in before, which may be a an apartment building and maybe a townhouse community. But it is no longer a condominium. And there may be, you know, a lot of reasons for pursuing this route, just given the history of condominiums in the United States. A lot of them are now 30, 40, 50 years old, getting towards the end of their useful life. So termination or de conversion is is one route that an association could take to wind down a condominium that no longer wants to continue. You've used two words termination and de-conversion. Are those significantly different or just different ways to phrase the same thing? I think we're really talking about the same concept. It is not a common occurrence, I would say, in the world of condominium. So it's it's getting more common. So the terminology we haven't really settled on the terminology. I think termination is used pretty frequently. Be you using evidence analogy to when you start a condominium, if you start a new condominium, you know, from the ground up, a new building, you create a condominium regime. If you have an apartment building and it's in a rental apartment building, and you want to change it from having one owner of the apartment building to owners of each of the units, you convert the building to a condominium. So is having said that, you know, the terminology terminology for conversion and de-conversion is is sort of in its infancy. And, you know, I guess if you looked at that very logically, you would say, oh, well, this building was converted from an apartment building. Now we're going to convert it. Whereas if it was never a add and not a condominium, if it if it was originally just a piece of ground and not a new building, then you're going to create a condominium and then terminate it. But I don't think that in practice practices how it's used in in some areas of the country. They talk it out, all forms of of discontinuing, continuing the condominium ownership as a deconversion in other parts of the country, like in Florida, they talk about it as a condominium termination. You know, actually, as we're talking about it, I remember reading about a conversion. I forget where it was converting from apartments to condominiums. And the developer didn't pick their timing well and was having a hard time selling. And so after a year or so, they just rolled it back to apartments and deconverted it. They only had a few units that had sold. The developer still owned a significant majority of the units and basically was admitting I made a mistake. The timing was bad. Let's roll it back to apartments because most of them are rented anyway, so it can take many flavors. Could be a developer move, it could be something that lasts for years. It could be short term, it could be long term. But I think the essence of what you're saying is it's owned by many people and then you get back into the process of ownership by just one person. Is that fair to say? Yeah, I think that's right. And it can be anywhere along the spectrum of complexity. I think, you know, the situation you were talking about, if we're if it's very soon after the creation or conversion of the condominium and it's still under developer control, then it's really just a paperwork issue. They you know, they filed a declaration to create the condominium that went from a single unified parcel of property to units in common areas. If it's still all under common ownership, then converting it back. Terminating the condominium is really a simple process. So you file one in in most jurisdictions you're filing one piece of paper and it just changes the form of ownership. Where it gets complicated is when you have multiple owners. So the units have been sold to different individual owners. They each have their own individual interests and views on what should happen. And that's where it really gets complex and more interesting because then you have to satisfy all the statutory requirements and the requirements in the condominium documents to get determination. I'm writing down questions here and I got a member to make sure I asked both of them. We talked a little bit about condo termination. Is this also HOA termination also or even co-op termination or is it all four forms of multiple owners, condos, townhomes, high rises and HOAs? Is it all forms? Well, there's a similarity between condominium and co-ops, but co-ops is a little bit different process. But but there's probably more similarities and differences. Co-ops. What you talk, Robert, before about the idea with a condo, you have one owner and then you go to many owners that with a termination, you go back to one owner with a co-op, the Co-op Corporation. He is the owner and the residents have retired or for top half have leases to their units. And so you have the co-op for similar reasons that we'll discuss, decided to to terminate. It would be the again it would not be the individual owners no longer owning their units because they are owner units. It would be the co-op corporation selling its interests but having to go through a similar process to get a significant majority of the end of the residents on board with with pursuing this action and the h.O.H. That there is nothing comparable to a HOA termination because an HOA doesn't own any property other than perhaps some common areas. They may own some streets, They don't own a stormwater management pond and a tennis court, you know, some a swimming pool. But the individual homeowners own and own their homes. And I'm not aware of any any methodology, statutes or otherwise. And a for a HOA to terminate and sell the the all of the property, including the homes that are individually owned to to to a single owner. But there are definitely similarities between co-ops and condos. Fantastic. Roger, thanks for that clarification. That brings up that second question, though, Evan, that you kind of introduced. It gets complicated at various levels of complexity, I think you said, but I can imagine a 100 unit association, 100 different people classically and then trying to get all those people on the same page. That can be a challenge, I would imagine. Is that fair? Yeah, I think that's right. And, you know, every community and every project is going to be a little bit different. I think what we've seen out in the world is that there are kind of common themes on why a condominium project may be looking at termination. I think one of the primary ones is that a lot of these buildings that were built as condominiums or converted into condominiums in the seventies and eighties when there was a real boom in condominium development, especially in coastal areas, are now reaching the end of their useful life, and they're facing these really steep maintenance costs they may have to undergo, you know, massive and expensive reconstruction efforts in order just to maintain the viability of their building. The unit owners may be unable or unwilling to pay those assessments. In other cases, these buildings are you know, the buildings themselves are older, are not as valuable as they once were, but are sitting on an extremely valuable piece of a piece of real estate. And the highest and best use of that real estate may be redevelop ment for, you know, a larger building, a more modern building that can get you know, that could get higher prices are higher rents and it may just make economic savvy to terminate the condominium and pursue something else with the property. Another scenario that we see is that, you know, a building may have been converted to condominiums in a market that where condominiums just never really took off. And it may make sense more sense as a professionally managed apartment building or a student housing complex or or some other use beyond a residential condominium. So, you know, it's not just the case of trying to convince 100 different actors out of the blue. A lot of times they're all facing the same pressures. And you know, seeing the writing on the wall in the same way. So they may be motivated by similar things. Yeah. Have a thank you for that. I hear you saying that people are seeing the writing on the wall and I've heard of situations where people hit get hit with a $50,000 special assessment and they say, Well, that's all my unit is worth. And that begs the question, is it viable to move forward? But you also said that when the land is very valuable, when there's maybe a Hilton a couple of doors down around the block or something else, and that tends to suggest maybe there's two phases to this, the conversion process, termination process. Can you explain the two different ways someone might drive the bus on this termination? Yeah, I think there really can come from two sides. I mean, it a termination is typically ultimately a sale of a property. So it's going to take a seller and a buyer in most cases that, you know, the seller is going to be the the owners acting through the association and the buyer is going to be a developer who has an idea of what they can do with the property. In most cases, they're either going to maintain the property in its current form. They may have some ideas to improve it and turn it into a rental property, or they may just be interested in the land and they want to tear down the existing building and and develop it into something else. The motivation could come from either either sides of that equation. It could be the association that, you know, is facing a difficult future and that, you know, they have a very expensive maintenance obligation. They have residents who don't want to continue paying very high assessments to maintain an aging and aging building. And they see termination as an exit strategy. It could come from the developer side where, you know, the developers look out for a profitable project. They see this particular piece of property as a likely candidate. And, you know, if that if it were a non condominium building, they might approach the owner of it and make an offer. It's a condominium building. So it's you know, there are there are a hundred different owners. So there is this process by which a developer can approach the association and make an offer and the owners can come together and accept it, which ultimately would result in termination and sale of the condominium. You spoke earlier about or I think Roger spoke about the the nuance difference between a condo and a co-op condo is 100 different owners, you know, are hypothetical today. A co-op is one entity, but 100 different shareholders. Is that fair? That's yeah, that's. That's that is correct. It's a process. And then just describe the what what leads to the decision to terminate to sell the property are similar under both of those scenarios are we just add that in addition to what you point out, Robert that owners facing substantial special assessments, seeing their building decline in value, not having, you know, all of the amenities and nice things that newer buildings have. Those are all factors that may lead in to collectively unit owners saying it is better and to for us to terminate. The other sort of motivating factors or influencing factors is in in some cases may be most cases and the owners, when this developer approaches them or the association will say we can actually pay you a premium for your unit, we can pay you more for your unit than you would ever be able to get on the on the market. And you don't have to pay any of those special assessments. You don't have to worry about any and any of those factors. And then the other thing that that is of a more recent vintage is now because of what happened with Surfside, now they the states and the local governments are coming into play and they're saying, well, that makes us look really bad. We we have we inspect these buildings. We gave building permits and then when a building like that collapses and there is this terrible tragedy that is not good for the government because people start saying, why? Why? How did you let this happen? Why didn't you know the condition of these buildings and so forth. And so now there has been a response in in some jurisdictions. And this seems to be growing, is that the governments through that condominium act or otherwise are saying condominiums, you must undertake a very extensive evaluation of your building and maybe you have to do that every five years. And not only does that evaluation have to tell you what the condition is of these components, it has to tell you what their remaining useful life is. Some things maybe need to be fixed or addressed immediately, some over the next three or five or ten years. Even the things that don't have to be fixed immediately. We are going to make you contribute now for for the future cost of those items. So so you have to establish reserves to do that that maybe had not been done before because these were just deferred maintenance items. So now the condominium is saying, my gosh, we have to spend thousands of dollars for this study. And this study tells us we've got a problem building there. We're going to have to spend a lot of money for. And at the same time, a developer is approaching them and say you don't have to worry about any of that. We will take the building off your hands and pay your premiums. So those are those are can be compelling factors that that respond to your question. Like what? How do you get, you know, a majority, a substantial majority of the owners agree to agree to a termination because they do have to agree to the termination. Well, that's that's why they might agree to give up their their homes. Yeah. The scenario, Roger, that you're painting is I can imagine a in an association where there's many owners, maybe a majority of unit owners that have been there a long time. It's been their home for 20 plus years and they are used to the monthly assessments at a certain level. They've budgeted for that and they're not used to. Now they are higher expenses due to outside factors or just the decades of deterioration, and I can imagine those would be some contentious board meetings where the board is saying, yeah, it's going to be expensive to live here. And that could unify the homeowners behind the idea that is there another way? And I think what we're talking about today is that other way, a crisis is a unifying factor and that can be good for the association. And now I have more questions. You mentioned, Roger, that there may be an opportunity for the homeowners to actually get a premium for the sale of their home if it's a situation where they've got a crushing special assessment that's about to be levied and they don't feel that they can afford that, they're not sure that the home value can afford it. They're realizing their dream home that they've been in for 20 years isn't worth as much as they thought it was. Is there is there a distinguishing characteristic between the ones that are crushing problems and the ones where there may be a developer around the corner standing ready, the white knight ready to rescue those homeowners? Well, I would say that that every situation, every project is going to be different going back to something happened and it said earlier, if if the property is in a very desirable and low base and if somebody can can take that property by tear down the existing old building that has all these problems and put something up that is far more valuable, then those problems are no longer problems. If you're going to be tearing the building down, you don't have to make all those repairs. You don't have to do all that remediation. On the other hand, if you have a piece of property that you know is not necessarily in a desirable location and there's nothing that somebody else can really do with the property to make it more valuable, you'll now then have perhaps a situation where the condominium says it doesn't make sense for us to put hundreds of thousands of dollars per unit out into this building because where we put all that money into the building because we need to to make it safe and habitable. And then after we do that, after we spend, you know,$500,000 per unit, we have units that are worth $250,000. You know why would we do that? And there may not be a white knight because somebody else says, well, this this property, because of the zoning, its location, future plans in the area is not a desirable thing. I might buy it from you, but I'm not going to pay you a premium. I will pay you maybe something less than that $250,000 that you otherwise could get. But you're only going to get that 250,000 after you address all these problems. You don't have to address the problems. I'll tear it down and maybe I'll make it a parking lot or I may get out of donated for a city park or something like like that. So. So there are, you know, situations where the burden of of dealing with the conditions of the building may be so significant, but there may not be a a a higher and best use for that property. But the situation is that definitely I have seen or observed tend to be more the situations where I'm that where there is a better use to the property and therefore this developer would be willing to pay a premium and be willing to take this obligation off of the homeowners hands. Yeah. A couple of follow ups to that. Clearly, every situation is going to be different. And I'm thinking the theme of this is an emergency exit. And an emergency exit gets you out alive. It's not necessarily pleasant. Pleasant would be great. I get more money than I thought I could have, but pleasant may also be I got a reasonable dollar amount for my unit and I'm not having to dig deep and come up with a huge special assessment and go through a year or more of reconstruction. And that's just it's painful even thinking about that. So an emergency exit may just be that it may just be a way out, a less painful way out than the consequence of living in a association that is gradually dying on its own. Eben, maybe you could talk about for a moment what's it look like when it's the developer that has a gleam in their thinking process? They think, Oh, I could do a parking lot, I could do a mixed use facility here. What's it look like when it's the developer that's driving the bus? Yeah, So the actual process for terminating and selling a condominium property is spelled out in a couple of places. It's in each state's condominium. Mark They're going to specify the steps that the parties would have to go through and the thresholds that they would have to meet, including the threshold of approval from the owners. And then it's spelled out in the individual condominium declaration, may have additional provisions in it, including possibly changing the increasing the threshold for approval. So a developer is going to have to be familiar with those rules and have a strategy for for for getting to the approval threshold. So that's usually the the biggest barrier. So there are a few ways that that can be accomplished. A developer can approach the association directly in a in a larger building where it's not feasible to deal with individual owners. They would probably approach the association and they could make an offer just like an offer for any other building. Most condominium acts have a process by which the association can negotiate and even enter into a contract for the sale of the property without the approval of the owners. But that in the contract is only valid once it's been ratified by the R, so it kind of flips the process on a tad from what you might expect. But the association is negotiating as a seller of the property with the developer, as the buyer, and then turning around and getting it, getting the sale ratified by its owners. In reality, it probably the owners are probably involved from the start, but that's the statutory framework is that the association is, is the seller under, under a purchase contract to the developer and then the the approval may come after the fact. Might it also be a very, very eager developer that starts buying up 1 to 5, ten different homes and is maybe just personally committed to forcing their way in? Does that happen? Yeah, so that that can happen. Another alternative to negotiating. There are a couple alternatives to negotiating with an association a developer could talk directly to owners could try to kind of create a groundswell among the owners to meet the threshold on the thresholds here are usually in the range of 80%. It's different for each state, but 80% is a pretty common threshold. So a developer could talk to individual owners and try to get them to put pressure on the association to sell the condominium building. And a developer also could start buying up units, as you said, and either get to the 80% threshold themself themselves or get to the point where the combination of the developer and owners who are on their side together reach the threshold so that that does happen, that it can create some some more complex and potentially negative situations. If a developer is kind of working from the inside like that, a developer who buys up a large portion of the units could have the ability to take over an association, you know, to hold the voting power in the association. They could cross the 80% threshold, but still have other owners in the building and have the ability to approve a sale unilaterally. They over the objection of those other owners, they could turn around and sell the property to themselves. There are all sorts of permutations of that that are not really adequately addressed by a lot of of the state laws. So a lot of interesting and potentially devious outcomes there. For those watching on video. They can see me squirming in my chair. For those of you listening, I am squirming in my chair. Just hearing about those kinds of things starts to sound a little bit like a hostile takeover of a publicly traded company. When someone buys large chunks of the shares of the stock, while I'm looking at the time and thinking that we should try to bring this to a close, just a couple of things to confirm. Having you mentioned a few times, 80%, that's not a hard and fast number. That's going to vary with state laws, governing documents, things like that. But it is a supermajority most likely. Yeah. Yeah. I don't have every percentage in front of me, but I think they vary from roughly two thirds, you know, 67% and in some states have 100% requirement. You have to get every owner on board, which as you can imagine is a is a hard task. Yeah. And then 80, 80% is is sort of what some of the motto acts have always had. And then since then they've been modified. And I just wanted to point out like one other variation, which is maybe a more common variation is when the developer developer doesn't want to take the risk of buying individual units and now owning 20% of the units that he may be paid a premium for and could never get to the threshold he needed. So what they'll often do is enter into a contract and they'll say, I will buy your unit for a premium, but I will only do so if I can get 80% of your neighbors to agree to sell their units. And now, you know, the 20% that have bought on are now going knocking on the door of their neighbors and saying, Hey, you really need to do this. He gets a good deal. But but I can't sell my unit to the developer unless you sell your unit as well. So there there there is up there is a a useful means of perhaps reaching an important critical mass. Very interesting. And we're again talking about community associations. And so it's majority control. And so 100% is going to be hard that any board who contacts their attorney, I would imagine that's their first step to find out what are the numbers for our association. Is that fair? Contact your attorney as a first step. Yeah, I think that's right. I think any any attorney who is used to dealing with condominium associations, they may not have specific experience with terminations because it's not a very common process, but they'll be familiar with the art and, well, at least know where to look to to provide some advice on what the relevant thresholds are in the in the state. Yeah, and I think another part of it as we draw this episode to a close is that it is majority rule, it is an emergency asset. It may not be all what unicorns and rainbows and it may be a bumpy ride, but it is an emergency exit. And I just think that's a fascinating concept that board members need to keep in the back of their minds as we see that continual aging of our community association industry. Well, thank you for joining us today, Evan and Roger. Please let our audience know how can they get in contact with you? Should they want some follow up information? Evan Yeah, I'm in the Baltimore office of Ballard Spahr, which is a national firm that covers a lot of practice areas. I'm in the real estate group, so we do a lot of condominium work, so I invite them to visit our website at Ballard Spahr And that's B A L L A R D S P A H R .com? Yes. And Roger. Yes, the same same thing. If you go to our website, you'll see a description of our real estate practice and you'll see, you know, links to to Eben and to myself and others in our real estate and group. And it has our contact information there. Fantastic. Well, that brings us to another episode of Common Sense for Common Areas. We hope you'll join us again next week and be encouraged and better equipped for the hard work you are doing, serving your association and sharing. I You've been listening to Common Sense for Common areas. If you like the show and would like to support us, you could do so in a number of ways. Subscribe to common sense for common areas wherever you find your favorite podcast and please share with another board member. Do us a huge favor by going to iTunes and leaving us a five star rating and review. You can also support us by supporting the brands that sponsor this program. You'll find links to the website and social media for Association Insights and Marketplace Association Reserves, Community Financials and Kevin Davis Insurance Services in the show Notes. But the most important thing you can do is to engage in the conversation, connect with Robert Nordlund, Kevin Davis and Julie Adelman on social media. Email your questions or voice memos to podcast at reserved Steadicam, or call our 24 seven voicemail line at 8052033130. This podcast was mixed and mastered by Stoke Light Video and Marketing with Stoke Light on your team, you'll reach more customers with marketing expertise that inspires action. See the show notes to connect with Stoke Light. Finally, remember that the views and opinions expressed by the podcast do not constitute legal advice. Please consult your own legal counsel before making important decisions.